Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of findings

From: Disparate compensation policies for research related injury in an era of multinational trials: a case study of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa

Country

Written

Policy

Voluntary insurance/Compulsory

Compensable injuries

Exclusions

Actors responsible for compensation

No fault compensation

Ajudicator

Legal enforceabi-lity

Brazil

Yes

No

All injuries; death

Failure to prove negligence

Sponsor

Investigator

Research Institution

No

Courts

Yes

Russia

Yes

Yes

Death, 1st, 2nd, 3rd degree disability, none disabling injuries

Economic losses

Psychological injuries

Sponsor

No

Insurance

Companies

Yes

India

Yes

No

All injuries including non trial related and economic losses

No

Sponsor

Yes

The Licensing

Authority; REC and Expert Committee

Yes

China

No

No

Product quality liability; Drug administration errors

Injuries due to medication and procedures that meet minimum national and industry standards

Sponsor

No

None

No

South Africa

Yes

Yes

Bodily injuries

Enduring injuries

Psychological injuries; non- enduring injuries

Sponsor

Strict liability

Courts

No