Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 3 Calculated ratios of top themes to all themes for committees participating in the three exercises

From: Measuring inconsistency in research ethics committee review

Exercise Committee identifier Top themes All themes Top theme: All themes
WHEAT 12 6 10 0.60
WHEAT 11 5 11 0.45
ShED19 14 4 9 0.44
ShED20 18 7 16 0.44
WHEAT 7 7 16 0.44
ShED20 19 6 14 0.43
ShED20 17 7 17 0.41
ShED20 16 7 18 0.39
ShED20 15 7 18 0.39
ShED20 10 10 26 0.38
ShED20 11 9 24 0.38
ShED20 12 8 22 0.36
WHEAT 5 8 22 0.36
ShED20 7 11 31 0.35
ShED20 4 13 37 0.35
ShED19 15 3 9 0.33
ShED20 13 7 21 0.33
ShED20 9 9 27 0.33
ShED20 3 13 39 0.33
WHEAT 9 5 15 0.33
ShED20 14 6 19 0.32
ShED20 8 9 29 0.31
ShED19 8 7 23 0.30
ShED20 6 10 33 0.30
ShED20 1 13 43 0.30
ShED19 12 6 20 0.30
WHEAT 10 3 11 0.27
WHEAT 2 7 26 0.27
ShED19 9 6 23 0.26
ShED19 7 6 23 0.26
WHEAT 4 6 23 0.26
WHEAT 8 4 16 0.25
ShED20 5 8 33 0.24
WHEAT 1 7 29 0.24
WHEAT 6 5 21 0.24
ShED20 2 9 41 0.22
ShED19 13 3 14 0.21
ShED19 11 4 20 0.20
ShED19 1 7 37 0.19
ShED19 4 6 32 0.19
ShED19 5 5 27 0.19
ShED19 10 4 23 0.17
ShED19 6 4 26 0.15
WHEAT 3 4 26 0.15
ShED19 3 5 35 0.14
ShED19 2 5 35 0.14