Skip to main content

Table 3 Calculated ratios of top themes to all themes for committees participating in the three exercises

From: Measuring inconsistency in research ethics committee review

Exercise

Committee identifier

Top themes

All themes

Top theme: All themes

WHEAT

12

6

10

0.60

WHEAT

11

5

11

0.45

ShED19

14

4

9

0.44

ShED20

18

7

16

0.44

WHEAT

7

7

16

0.44

ShED20

19

6

14

0.43

ShED20

17

7

17

0.41

ShED20

16

7

18

0.39

ShED20

15

7

18

0.39

ShED20

10

10

26

0.38

ShED20

11

9

24

0.38

ShED20

12

8

22

0.36

WHEAT

5

8

22

0.36

ShED20

7

11

31

0.35

ShED20

4

13

37

0.35

ShED19

15

3

9

0.33

ShED20

13

7

21

0.33

ShED20

9

9

27

0.33

ShED20

3

13

39

0.33

WHEAT

9

5

15

0.33

ShED20

14

6

19

0.32

ShED20

8

9

29

0.31

ShED19

8

7

23

0.30

ShED20

6

10

33

0.30

ShED20

1

13

43

0.30

ShED19

12

6

20

0.30

WHEAT

10

3

11

0.27

WHEAT

2

7

26

0.27

ShED19

9

6

23

0.26

ShED19

7

6

23

0.26

WHEAT

4

6

23

0.26

WHEAT

8

4

16

0.25

ShED20

5

8

33

0.24

WHEAT

1

7

29

0.24

WHEAT

6

5

21

0.24

ShED20

2

9

41

0.22

ShED19

13

3

14

0.21

ShED19

11

4

20

0.20

ShED19

1

7

37

0.19

ShED19

4

6

32

0.19

ShED19

5

5

27

0.19

ShED19

10

4

23

0.17

ShED19

6

4

26

0.15

WHEAT

3

4

26

0.15

ShED19

3

5

35

0.14

ShED19

2

5

35

0.14