Skip to main content

Table 1 Proportion of conscientious objectors and women who obtained a voluntary abortion promptly (≤14 days) or later (22-28 days): three comparisons

From: The no correlation argument: can the morality of conscientious objection be empirically supported? the Italian case

 

Gyn. objectors

% (n)

 

Waiting time ≤ 14 days

% (n)

 

Waiting time 22-28 days

% (n)

 

Comparison (2006 vs 2009) proposed by the Italian Commitee for Bioethics

 

2006

2009

changes

2006

2009

changes

2006

2009

changes

Italy

69.2 (3780)

70.7 (3985)

56.7 (68217)

59.3 (65919)

12.4 (14875)

11.1 (12313)

  Latium

77.7 (443)

80.2 (315)

47.8 (7190)

54.0 (7070)

17.2 (2584)

13.3 (1738)

  Piedmont

62.9 (285)

63.8 (284)

51.1 (5635)

60.1 (5705)

13.7 (1508)

10.8 (1020)

  Lombardy

68.6 (578)

66.9 (560)

58.6 (12763)

56.0 (9868)

11.3 (2463)

11.5 (2024)

  Umbria

70.2 (73)

63.3 (62)

51.0 (1089)

40.0 (754)

13.3 (284)

19.0 (358)

  Emilia-Romagna

53.5 (198)

52.4 (205)

56.8 (6510)

62.0 (6712)

11.1 (1274)

8.3 (899)

Comparison (2006 vs 2013) proposed by the Italian Ministry of Health

 

2006

2013

 

2006

2013

 

2006

2013

 

Italy

69.2 (3780)

70.0 (3481)

56.7 (68217)

62.3 (61254)

12.4 (14875)

10.2 (10013)

  Latium

77.7 (443)

80.7 (314)

47.8 (7190)

54.0 (6020)

17.2 (2584)

13.5 (1509)

  Piedmont

62.9 (285)

67.4 (269)

51.1 (5635)

68.3 (5775)

13.7 (1508)

7.4 (626)

  Lombardy

68.6 (578)

63.6 (565)

58.6 (12763)

54.4 (8708)

11.3 (2463)

13.5 (2157)

  Umbria

70.2 (73)

65.6 (63)

51.0 (1089)

43.8 (717)

13.3 (284)

17.6 (288)

  Emilia-Romagna

53.5 (198)

51.8 (231)

56.8 (6510)

73.7 (6754)

11.1 (1274)

4.8 (442)

Comparison (2009 vs 2013) proposed by the authors

 

2009

2013

 

2009

2013

 

2009

2013

 

Italy

70.7 (3985)

70.0 (3481)

59.3 (65919)

62.3 (61254)

11.1 (12313)

10.2 (10013)

  Latium

80.2 (315)

80.7 (314)

54.0 (7070)

54.0 (6020)

13.3 (1738)

13.5 (1509)

  Piedmont

63.8 (284)

67.4 (269)

60.1 (5705)

68.3 (5775)

10.8 (1020)

7.4 (626)

  Lombardy

66.9 (560)

63.6 (565)

56.0 (9868)

54.4 (8708)

11.5 (2024)

13.5 (2157)

  Umbria

63.3 (62)

65.6 (63)

40.0 (754)

43.8 (717)

19.0 (358)

17.6 (288)

  Emilia-Romagna

52.4 (205)

51.8 (231)

62.0 (6712)

73.7 (6754)

8.3 (899)

4.8 (442)

  1. Data refer to those cited in ‘The no correlation argument’ section of the paper and are an extract of data published in the 2012 opinion of the Italian Committee for Bioethics (2006 vs 2009) and in the 2015 Ministerial report (2006 vs 2013). : the proportion increased; : the proportion decreased; : the proportion did not change