Skip to main content

Table 1 Mean value quality analysis of vignettes

From: Measuring value sensitivity in medicine

Quality-criteria

Moral ambiguity

 

Comprehensibility

Expert knowledge

Relation to reality

Strategic

Moral

Δ

Vignette No

M

(SD)

M

(SD)

M

(SD)

M

(SD)

M

(SD)

(SD)

p

1

1.63

(0.89)

1.69

(0.80)

1.62

(0.62)

4.19

(0.98)

4.19

(0.75)

(1.42)

1.000

2

1.76

(0.83)

1.94

(1.03)

2.12

(0.86)

4.65

(0.79)

3.41

(1.00)

(1.25)

0.001**

3

1.63

(0.89)

2.81

(1.11)

1.38

(0.62)

3.38

(1.54)

3.88

(0.89)

(1.86)

0.300

4

1.82

(0.81)

2.59

(1.00)

2.18

(0.88)

4.59

(0.62)

3.82

(1.02)

(1.26)

0.023*

5

1.41

(0.87)

1.59

(1.00)

2.24

(0.75)

4.18

(0.95)

4.29

(0.85)

(0.78)

0.543

6

2.5

(1.32)

2.63

(1.31)

1.69

(0.70)

3.53

(1.06)

3.53

(0.83)

(1.46)

1.000

7

1.89

(0.94)

3.16

(1.07)

1.79

(0.86)

4.21

(1.03)

4.26

(0.93)

(1.13)

0.841

8

1.35

(0.59)

2.35

(1.23)

1.75

(0.91)

4.1

(0.97)

4.95

(0.22)

(0.99)

0.001**

9

1.84

(1.17)

3.26

(1.05)

2.47

(1.17)

2.53

(1.07)

4.21

(0.98)

(1.29)

0.000***

10

1.52

(0.81)

2.62

(1.12)

1.29

(0.56)

3.81

(1.03)

4.9

(0.30)

(1.04)

0.000***

11

1.83

(0.86)

2.33

(1.24)

2.5

(0.86)

4.61

(1.15)

3.56

(1.34)

(1.83)

0.026*

12

1.62

(0.5)

2.75

(0.93)

1.75

(0.68)

3.44

(1.41)

4.75

(0.78)

(1.49)

0.003**

  1. remark : vignettes (bold) were selected if: Mcomprehensibility ≤ 2.5, 1.5 < Mexpert_knowledge < 3.5, Mrelation_to_reality < 2.5, Mmoral/strategic < 4.5, Δns; *p < .05, ** p < .01, *** p < .001