Skip to main content

Table 1 Study Characteristics

From: Culturally appropriate consent processes for community-driven indigenous child health research: a scoping review

Author

Year

Location

Objective

Study Population

# of Children/

Youth

# of Adults

Child/Youth Consent Method

Parental Consent Method

Stiffman et al.

2005

USA

To report on the pressures between research and ethics in a study of service use in AIa youth.

Youth, 12–19

401

0

Written consent

Written

Panagiotopoulos et al.

2007

Canada

To implement a children’s diabetes screening program.

Children, 6–18

29

0

Written assent

Written

Baydala et al.

2011

Canada

To discuss the challenges of gathering child assent during a CBPRb project.

Research team members

0

7

N/A

N/A

Rose et al.

2011

New Zealand

To gather ideas on promoting return of consent forms and vaccine uptake among minority groups.

School staff

0

456

N/A

N/A

Fletcher et al.

2012

Canada

To develop recommendations for managing ethical consent in research with Aboriginal communities.

Research team members

0

7

N/A

N/A

Jardine & James

2012

Canada

To examine benefits, limitations and ethical issues when conducting peer participatory research.

Students, Grades 2–12

48

0

Oral assent

Written/

oral

Yao et al.

2018

USA

To test a text message intervention to promote sexual health among AIa and Alaska Native youth.

Youth, 15–18

408

0

Texted consent

Waived

Chadwick et al.

2019

USA

To test financial incentives for physical activity by overweight/obese adolescents.

AIa youth, 11–20

116

0

Consent

Written

Wagner et al.

2020

Australia

To assess a cognitive regulation intervention in remote Australian Aboriginal schools.

Students, Grades 1–6

271

440

Written consent

Written

Anderson et al.

2021

Australia

To evaluate the effectiveness and feasibility of online yarning circles with ATSIc Australian youth.

ATSIc youth, 18–24

21

0

Email or verbal consent

N/A

Siller et al.

2021

USA

To explore the reactions of Native American adolescents to research on sexual violence.

Students, Grades 6–12

149

0

Written assent

Written

  1. aAmerican Indian; bCommunity-based participatory research; cAboriginal and Torres Strait Islander