Skip to main content

Table 5 Proposed recommendations to prevent non-medical use of methylphenidate (MPH) and challenges associated with prevention.

From: Disagreements with implications: diverging discourses on the ethics of non-medical use of methylphenidate for performance enhancement

A. Proposed recommendations to prevent non-medical use of MPH

Print media

Bioethics

Public health

Diagnosing ADHD more carefully [37, 38, 50]

Supervising of students with stimulant prescriptions [33, 47]

Teaching students effective study skills and stress management [17, 37]

Informing students and staff of the dangers of abusing prescription drugs [18, 33, 34, 37]

Criminalizing non-approved uses of medications [3, 48]

Prohibiting prescription of drugs for lifestyle purposes by doctors [48]

Obliging manufacturers to declare safety data for unapproved uses to the FDA [48]

Subsidizing cognition enhancing drugs to allow equal access [40, 48]

Establishing a "ceiling" as the maximum cognitive enhancement permissible [48, 53]

Ensuring prescription compliance and responsible prescription practices [49, 52]

Prescribing preparations that are less easily abused [41, 51]

Identifying persons who are liable to abuse medication [49]

Educating healthcare providers dealing with university populations as to the abuse potential of stimulants [51, 52]

B. Identified challenges in the prevention of non-medical use of MPH

Print media

Bioethics

Public health

Logistical problems of enforcing a ban [37, 38, 54]

Perceived safety of MPH makes convincing students about its dangers more difficult [35, 37]

Abundance of MPH in healthcare system [50]

Misuse of MPH bypasses traditional sources of information on indications and risks when taking a prescription medication [37]

Difficult to propose a ban on cognitive enhancers because of their routine use in treatment [40, 48, 53]

Ban is liable to encourage a black market and be just as coercive as social pressure [40, 48, 53]

FDA has little experience in assessing social cost/benefit of a drug and thus is unfit to take charge of such regulation [53]

None identified